The Black experience of transgenerational trauma has unfolded across several centuries, subjugating and enslaving a people for some four hundred years. The profound effects of this insidious trauma, and the deleterious transmissions it generates, continue to be re-enacted across many domains of Black life.
The historiography of slavery is frequently framed from the premise that it belongs to a distant past, one that ought to be relinquished and moved beyond. With this view, its present-day beneficiaries need not concern themselves with the crimes of their forebears and may reasonably expect to live unburdened by reminders of that history, since such reminders threaten to evoke both shame and guilt. My contention is that this very disavowal constitutes a significant injury in its own right, one that perpetuates the mechanisms and the harm of transgenerational trauma. The recognition of one’s trauma is, after all, the first step toward reconciliation and healing.
The failure of the white colonizing world to recognize the historical trauma of Black people, together with the broader international failure to acknowledge its impact upon a segment of humanity, contributes substantially to an arrested state of being, and therefore of development, within the Black diaspora. It is precisely the persistence of this historical wound into contemporary struggle that constitutes the defining feature of intergenerational trauma.
One of the core legacies of transgenerational and intergenerational trauma is shame, and its role in the wounding of Black identity. The internalization of racial oppression exacts a considerable toll, contributing to a pervasive affliction of the self.
A particularly painful form of shame is one that, left unaddressed, may become toxic. Unlike shame arising from a single incident, toxic shame remains lodged within and is absorbed into our very self-identity. The person who suffers from toxic shame experiences a chronic sense of worthlessness, a diminished self-esteem and a pervasive self-loathing, each bound to the conviction that they are innately shameful or bad.
Toxic shame originating in transgenerational trauma is liable to continual arousal in the present, through repeated experiences of rejection and betrayal by a society that consigns minorities to the margins of humanity. It functions as a formidable internal adversary, one that works to diminish the self and disposes either the individual or the group toward apathy and compliance with the status quo.
Working with toxic shame is a considerable challenge, because the practitioner must attend to both the individual and the collective dimensions of shame trauma. For white therapists in particular, a sustained mindfulness is crucial, lest they reproduce the very rupture that re-shaming the shamed inevitably occasions.
Shame cycle
I suggest that shame-based individuals have difficulty in achieving healthy individuation (the process of coming into and maturing into one’s full identity), as they are locked in a damaging shame cycle. I suggest that such a cycle has four stages:
- Shame is induced in individuals through interpersonal interactions that lead to the production of shame
- Shame is internalized and eventually consumes our inner core
- The internalization of shame creates a process of internally disowning parts of the self. Gershen Kaufman labeled this ‘splitting’
- Splitting creates painful internal discrepancies that we attempt to correct, without much success, because the self-hate associated with the disowned, fragmented part creates repeated patterns and cycles, any time shame is triggered.
The recollection of this episode of shame is sufficiently potent to summon once again the powerful and familiar presence of “racial hauntings,” which arise in the aftermath of some injurious experience. The injury may take the form of microaggressions, of racism in any of its guises, of social injustice, or of the continual displacements, denials, projections and disavowed material directed by the white other onto Black others.
For Black people, the very familiarity of these experiences serves to reopen what is presumed to belong to the past, namely the pain of a brutal history of Black/white relations, so that it is experienced anew in the present, and haunts the soul.
Constant Trigger
At the simplest level, the presence of the therapists’ white face or Black face may serve as a persistent trigger for the client’s shame. The therapist’s relationship with their own racial identity, and what that identity comes to represent for the client within the transference, must therefore be addressed. At a more profound level, the therapist will re-shame and burden the client should the work fall short of an engaged and attuned curiosity, and of an adequate working through and holding of the client’s vulnerabilities.
The cultivation of an effective working alliance is essential, for it guards against the acting out of unconscious dynamics within the therapy. In addressing toxic shame and the wounding of Black identity, it becomes all the more important to render conscious the unconscious dimension of the working relationship, so that relational dynamics are not left unattended, to fester and generate further shame that invariably re-shames the shamed.
The principal aim in addressing the shame-trauma cycle that wounds identity is to enable the client to disentangle themselves from the familiar and destructive patterns of internalized shame, patterns that keep both the burden of heritage (the historical past) and generational hauntings (present-day racialized triggers) alive and operative.
Identity Trauma
Race-based shame exposes Black and white people alike, albeit in different ways. Black shame is concerned essentially with identity trauma, with hurt and loss; white shame, by contrast, triggers a fear of identity exposure, a matter of guilt and vulnerability. When these unheeded dimensions are enacted, whether consciously or unconsciously, within the therapeutic encounter, it is frequently the case that the white therapist’s disavowed shame is consigned to the Black client for safekeeping. Shame overarches much of what proves difficult in Black/white relations, and it is my belief that the ubiquity of shame is itself a driving force that brings clients to therapy. Shame resides wherever there is psychological pain.
The Internal Oppressor
Black internalized oppression is the process or act of absorbing, whether consciously or unconsciously, the values and beliefs of the oppressor, and of subscribing to the stereotypes and misinformation propagated about one’s own group. Such a process gives rise to low self-esteem, to self-hatred, to the disowning of one’s own group and of other minority groups alike, and to a range of complex, defensive interpersonal behaviors that impair the quality of life.
I maintain that the internal oppressor, that aspect of the self which becomes the inner tyrant or enemy, is to be distinguished from internalized oppression. Like shame, the internal oppressor is an aspect of the self that retains historical and intergenerational baggage and re-enacts the transmission of trauma across the generations.
Shame is inextricably bound to the internal oppressor. Shame declares: “I am bad, unworthy, not good enough, unlovable.” The internal oppressor is my internal adversary, my own enemy, my discrediting self.
With respect to Black/white relations, the internal oppressor engenders a post-slavery and post-colonial mindset that colors the dealings of Black people with the white other. It shapes our interrelational dynamics and our patterns of attachment to this other, and may even collude, unconsciously, with the prevailing external difficulties.
Crucially, the internal oppressor appears to be ever present, yet it lies dormant for the most part. Only upon contact with the external oppressive situation, be it real, perceived, or some combination of the two, are the historical memories reawakened, old wounds reopened, and the self and identity subjected to a silent and invisible re-wounding.
Prejudices, projections, intergenerational wounds and the vicissitudes of our historical past are all aspects of this inner tyrant. They are sustained within the transgenerational transmission of trauma, which suggests a measure of persistent post-traumatic syndrome in the lived existence of Black people.
Societal perceptions of Blackness carry a great many negative connotations, and their impact upon Black people is varied. Some have come to anticipate this negativity and have accommodated it through a process of transcendence. Others are perpetually triggered into angry responses and act out their feelings. For still others, the discomfort of living with this ever-present split, the discrepancy between public and private identity, exacts its toll and issues in inner disturbance, particularly when it is compounded by other present or latent personal difficulties and life struggles.
The puncturing of a Black person’s identity, the disjunction between the truth of how they genuinely know themselves and the contrasting, negative ways in which society treats them, can destabilize a person’s ontology, their mental equilibrium and their rootedness in being in the world. Where race relations are concerned, the battleground is at once personal and political.
Creating an Effective Working Alliance is Key
Identity shame is bound to historical wounding, yet at its deepest level it issues from a more fundamental loss: that of not possessing a rightful place in the human world.
I posit that, at an unconscious level, Black people are still not perceived as fully actualized human beings, and that the Black male in particular is cast as not merely subhuman but dangerous, a figure to be feared. Because this dimension of race goes unspoken, the dominant other harbors the irrational belief somewhere within the collective psyche; and, as with all unheeded phenomena, both an acting out (the perpetuation of racism and identity shaming) and an acting in (the shame wound, with its persistent sense of incompleteness and abnormality) continue to thrive. This shame arises from the internalized conflict the self endures in negotiating external authority while seeking to protect its innermost and most vulnerable parts. Its function is to defend against an anxiety that threatens to destroy an integral image of the self; but in doing so, it shrouds the very actualization and integration it might otherwise permit.
Though shame is a universal experience, it assumes different dimensions within the Black and white context of history, heritage and identity. Black identity shame is the burden of carrying deep-rooted wounds and ongoing struggles, borne in relation to the dominance of the white other. This defense against white shame invariably compromises the quality of engagement in conversations about race, for the shamed person grows self-absorbed and preoccupied with self-protection. Such dynamics stymie these conversations and subject them to constant rupture; a retreat into old social scripts leaves the great weight of race work to be carried by the Black other. The imperative, then, is for the white other to own the primitive within.
One may thus conclude that white shame is a complex affective and cognitive reaction pattern that shapes character and attitude so as to prevent dangerous exposure, whereas Black identity shame is a complex affective and cognitive reaction to identity wounding itself.
Only we, Black folk, can heal our own wounds. And yet, as with any experience of trauma, there persists the relational dynamic of the wounded and the violator, for injury of this profundity requires a repair involving both parties, the sufferer and the one who has contributed to the suffering. Black trauma has its genesis in white colonial oppression; healing is therefore not a task for Black people alone, but a process requiring a formal reckoning with the impact of the oppressor’s wrongdoing. It is precisely in the evasion of this moral imperative, the failure to reckon with colonial legacies, that hidden white identity shame resides, and with it the burden of heritage borne by Black lives.
May you heal from strength to strength,
Dr. Paula Smith








