Couples counseling has been compared to “assembling an airplane in flight.” Two people are trying to repair something they still depend on. They’re doing it while it’s moving, while it’s under strain, and often while they argue over the blueprints. Sessions can be stressful, volatile and sometimes explosive.
So you want a trained pilot at the controls.
Not every counselor is trained for that kind of turbulence. Many social workers, psychologists and licensed counselors offer couples therapy, and plenty of them do it well. But a general license doesn’t guarantee specialized training, or much experience working with two people in the room at once.
Not every counselor is trained for that kind of turbulence. Many social workers, psychologists and licensed counselors offer couples therapy, and plenty of them do it well. But a general license doesn’t guarantee specialized training, or much experience working with two people in the room at once. Becoming a Certified Imago Relationship Therapist goes well beyond a graduate degree. The training starts only after a master’s degree, and it includes:
- 10 days of training in Imago theory and practice
- Attending a Getting the Love You Want couples workshop, so the therapist has been through the process from the couple’s side
- Six months of supervised clinical work
- A 90-minute recorded session that Imago faculty and colleagues review. To pass, the therapist must keep the couple in structured, connected dialogue for at least 90 percent of the session, rather than letting it slide back into argument or one-on-one exchanges with the therapist.
The training takes a substantial investment of time and money. That’s part of what sets it apart: it’s a commitment to couples work as a specialty, not an add-on.
“Unfortunately, many therapists have not been trained to step out of the who’s-to-blame dynamic.”
That matters. Studies of couples therapy have found that outcomes tend to suffer when partners feel differently about the therapist, for example when one feels understood and the other feels judged. A couple in that spot may stop coming. They may even decide the relationship is hopeless when the real problem was the approach.
Why an individual lens can backfire
Individual therapy is built around one person’s inner world: their history, their symptoms, their patterns. That focus is a strength when you’re working with one person. In a couples session, the same lens can quietly turn one partner into “the patient” and the other into a co-therapist. Once that happens, the work is already off balance.
Good couples therapy doesn’t ignore the past. Imago work in particular pays close attention to how early experiences shape what we look for in a partner and what we react to. The difference is the purpose. The goal isn’t to diagnose one person. It’s to understand how each partner’s history shows up between them, in the pattern(s) they create together.
Think of two dancers who keep stepping on each other’s feet. Studying one dancer’s footwork won’t fix the dance. You have to watch how they move together.
Treating the system, not the symptom
As an Imago therapist, I’ve learned to treat the system, not the symptom. If I don’t pay attention to the system, one partner will end up feeling betrayed, left out, reactive or resentful, and won’t want to come back.
Take one of the most common patterns I see. One partner reaches for connection with questions, criticism, tears or a louder voice. The other pulls back to calm things down by going quiet, changing the subject or leaving the room. Each move sets off the other: the more one pursues, the more the other withdraws, and the reverse. This is often pictured as the stoic husband and the emotional wife. In practice it shows up across all genders, in same-sex couples, non-binary and partners can swap roles depending on the issue.
My job is to help both partners see the cycle clearly, so each can change their part and neither carries all the blame. What I don’t do is name one partner’s quietness, or the other’s intensity, as the problem. That’s a reliable way to lose the person who may have been least sure about coming in the first place.
Balanced doesn’t mean “anything goes”
People often come to therapy hoping the therapist will finally agree that their partner is, in fact, a useless slug or a jerk. It’s easy to get pulled into one partner’s version of events, especially when it’s told with real pain.
Some approaches let the therapist act as referee: hear both stories, decide who’s right and break the tie. But taking sides, or even seeming to, usually sets the work back.
Being balanced is not the same as being passive. I will name hurtful behavior directly, such as contempt, stonewalling, broken agreements or harsh words. I’ll do it in a way that holds both partners with respect, so the goal stays accountability rather than a verdict on who wins.
When couples therapy isn’t the right first step
Joint sessions aren’t safe or helpful for every couple. Sometimes there is physical violence, threats, intimidation or controlling behavior, or one partner is afraid to speak openly at home or in the room. In those cases, couples work can increase the risk. That’s why I check in with each partner individually. When safety is a concern, I may recommend individual support or specialized services first.
Other situations may also need attention before or alongside couples work: an active addiction, an affair that’s still going on, or one partner who has already decided to leave.
The relationship is the client, and so are you both
The real client in couples therapy is the relationship. But a relationship is made of two people, and each needs to feel safe, heard and treated fairly for the work to hold.
When the temperature in the room rises, you need a steady guide both of you trust. That guide doesn’t take the controls away from you. They keep the plane level while you learn to fly it together.
“Can I cut people off? Can I intervene? Can I redirect? Can you draw out emotions? Can I build a bridge between the two people?
One of the most important questions people should ask when seeking a therapist is how much of their practice is devoted to couples. Most therapists will say, 30%.
What Good Couples Therapy Looks Like, and What It Doesn’t
My practice is entirely devoted to couples. I don’t fit couples in around an individual caseload. Working with two people at once is the work I do. That focus has taught me how easily couples therapy can go wrong, even with a caring, well-trained clinician in the chair.
Common missteps
Some missteps I see when a therapist is newer to couples work:
- Taking sides, or seeming to. This can be as subtle as nodding more for one partner, giving one person more airtime, or accepting one person’s version of events as the starting point.
- Letting conflict run unchecked. Strong feeling belongs in the room, because that’s often where the real work is. But when partners talk over each other, trade blame and escalate until one or both shut down, nobody is learning anything new. A skilled therapist slows the conversation so emotion becomes understanding instead of damage.
- Offering tips instead of change. “Use I-statements” is fine advice, but it rarely sticks unless the therapist also helps the couple see and change the deeper cycle that keeps pulling them apart.
- Leaving the work in the office. Change happens between sessions. Each partner should leave with something concrete and doable to practice before you meet again, such as a structured conversation or one new response to an old trigger. It shouldn’t be busywork.
- Judging the relationship’s worth. Weighing pros and cons out loud, or suggesting the partners might be better off apart, puts the therapist in a seat that belongs to the couple.
That last point has one important exception. When there’s abuse, intimidation or coercive control, safety comes first.
Happiness as a byproduct, not a target
Every therapist brings values into the room, whether they say so or not. I’d rather be open about mine. I don’t see a relationship as just a vehicle for each person’s individual happiness, to be traded in when it stops delivering.
That doesn’t mean anyone should stay stuck in misery. But some psychological research suggests that chasing happiness directly can backfire, and that people who make it their main goal often end up feeling worse. Happiness tends to show up as a byproduct of a meaningful life: close relationships, commitments kept and a sense of contributing something. It’s a bit like sleep. The harder you try to force it, the further away it gets.
Holding that value doesn’t mean I override yours. Each partner keeps the right to make their own decision about the relationship. My job is to make sure that decision is made with clarity, not in the fog of the worst stretch of the conflict.
When one partner is leaning out
I didn’t always practice this way. Early in my career, I brought an individual lens to couples work. If one partner didn’t want to save the marriage, I didn’t see how it could be saved.
I’ve since learned how common that situation is. Estimates suggest roughly one in three couples who come to therapy are “mixed-agenda” couples: one partner is leaning in, hoping to repair things, and the other is leaning out, unsure whether to try at all.
Not every marriage can or should be saved. But it isn’t the therapist’s role to decide which ones. I won’t be the first person in the room to give up. I’ll also respect a partner who isn’t ready to commit to the work. When one person is truly undecided, a short, structured process focused on clarity, sometimes called discernment counseling, can come before full couples therapy. It helps the leaning-out partner decide whether to try, without pressure in either direction.
How to tell if therapy is working
You should be able to tell fairly early whether therapy is a good fit. Within the first couple of sessions, each of you should feel that the therapist understands your point of view, not just your partner’s. You should also feel that sessions have a clear structure and direction, rather than drifting from one argument to the next.
Many couples notice meaningful improvement within about ten to 20 sessions. Couples with long-standing injuries, an affair or other added stressors may need longer. If you’re not seeing any change, it’s worth naming that openly with your therapist.
A major review in the Journal of Marital and Family Therapy found that couples therapy produces positive change for about 70 percent of couples. Done poorly, though, it can leave a relationship more polarized than before.
What about individual therapy?
Individual therapy is valuable for many things, but there’s little evidence that it resolves relationship problems on its own. It can even make them worse. The absent partner isn’t there to give their side, and a caring therapist naturally sympathizes with the person in the room. Sessions can drift into a place to vent about the relationship, and the partner at home can start to seem more and more like the villain. The couple grows further apart.
That said, individual therapy is sometimes the right call, either alongside couples work or before it, for example when:
- one partner is dealing with depression, anxiety, trauma or addiction
- there are safety concerns
- someone needs space to work out their own ambivalence
The line between personal and relationship problems is rarely neat. Depression can strain a relationship, and relationship distress can bring on or deepen depression. Couples therapy itself can be an effective part of treating depression and anxiety when the relationship is part of the picture.
The most helpful approach is usually to bring the partner in when it’s safe and possible, so the person who isn’t there doesn’t become just a character in someone else’s story.
Dr. Paula Smith – 401-782-7899








